Skip to main content
    SpinDepth
    SpinDepth
    News

    MSCI drops Prajogo's Barito Pacific and Jakarta purges 300 tightly held stocks: inside the clean up of the world's worst stock market

    By SpinDepth · APAC Briefing desk

    7 min read
    MSCI drops Prajogo's Barito Pacific and Jakarta purges 300 tightly held stocks: inside the clean up of the world's worst stock market

    How small has Indonesia become in MSCI's main emerging markets benchmark? The MSCI Indonesia Index had already shrunk to nine companies after six removals in May and two in August. In its November review, MSCI removed PT Barito Pacific, the energy and petrochemicals group controlled by billionaire Prajogo Pangestu, from its Global Standard Indexes and moved PT Bumi Resources Minerals down to its small cap index, without adding a single Indonesian stock, The Business Times reported.

    On the same day, Jakarta answered with its own purge. The Indonesia Stock Exchange said it would add about 300 more stocks to its high shareholder concentration list, a register of companies too tightly held to stay in its benchmark or in MSCI's indexes. Together, the two moves show how far Indonesia is willing to shrink its own market to keep foreign index money from leaving altogether.

    What MSCI did, and why it matters

    MSCI's November review was based on prices up to 20 October and takes effect after the market closes on 30 November, Indonesia Business Post reported. Funds that track MSCI's indexes will have to sell Barito Pacific before that date, and any fund benchmarked to the standard index will cut its Bumi Resources Minerals holding as the stock moves to the small cap segment, where far less money follows it.

    Indonesia was not alone. China had 38 deletions from the standard indexes, Japan five and Taiwan four, and in Southeast Asia the Philippines lost two members, Manila Electric and PLDT, while Singapore lost one. But Indonesia is the market where each removal hurts most, because MSCI has already warned that the whole country could be reclassified from an emerging market to a standalone market, a far harsher outcome than losing individual names.

    MSCI is taking feedback on that proposal until 30 April 2027 and will decide by 30 June, The Business Times reported. Goldman Sachs has estimated that excluding Indonesian stocks could trigger another 5.6 billion dollars of passive outflows, on top of the roughly 5.4 billion dollars foreign investors have already pulled from Indonesian equities this year.

    The Philippine changes show the pressure is regional, not only Indonesian. Manila Electric and PLDT, two of the Philippines' best known companies, lost their places in the standard index in the same review, at a time when the Philippine economy grew only 2.1 percent in the third quarter and the peso hit record lows. For Southeast Asian markets, every quarterly review is now a test of whether their largest companies are still big and liquid enough for global funds.

    The 300 stock purge

    The exchange's answer is to clean up the market before MSCI does it for them. Indonesia Stock Exchange chief executive Jeffrey Hendrik said the bourse would remove a market value threshold of 5 trillion rupiah for its high shareholder concentration list and add new criteria, including stocks where 10 or fewer holders own at least 92.5 percent of the shares, Bloomberg reported via The Business Times. It will also drop a price impact ratio that measured how far a share moved relative to its trading.

    About 300 more stocks will join the 83 already on the list, leaving roughly a third of index members ineligible for the benchmark. The newcomers represent about 6.16 percent of the Jakarta Composite Index's market value. Companies on the list are removed from both the JCI and MSCI indexes, and can only get off it if their controlling shareholders sell stock to the public in regular market trading.

    Citigroup analysts said the authorities' recent actions were decent but that more efforts are likely needed to avoid a downgrade. The regulators have also fined companies and individuals for market manipulation, as we reported in our story on Indonesia's record fines, and required more detailed disclosure of who owns what.

    Indonesia is shrinking its own stock market to save it. A third of the benchmark's members will be barred until their owners sell shares to the public.

    SpinDepth Research
    Trading screens at the Indonesia Stock Exchange in Jakarta
    About 300 more stocks, worth about 6.16 percent of the index, will join the exchange's concentration list Image: businesstimes.com.sg.

    Why concentrated ownership is the core problem

    MSCI's complaint is simple: it cannot trust the free float, the share of a company that ordinary investors can actually buy. When a handful of holders own almost all of a company, a small amount of trading can move the price dramatically, and index funds that must buy according to market value end up paying for valuations that were never tested by a real market. MSCI warned in October about opaque shareholding structures and coordinated trading.

    That is why some of Indonesia's biggest fortunes are tied up in this fight. Shares in companies controlled by a few tycoons soared over several years on thin free floats, then fell hard when MSCI raised its concerns, as we showed in our analysis of how Indonesia's richest lost 57 billion dollars. Barito Pacific's removal is part of that story.

    The cost has fallen on everyone else too. The Jakarta Composite Index has dropped more than 41 percent this year, the worst performance of any major stock market, and the rupiah hit a record 18,241 per dollar on 12 November, Bloomberg reported via The Straits Times.

    The MSCI logo on a screen
    MSCI's November review removed two Indonesian companies from its Global Standard Indexes and added none Image: indonesiabusinesspost.com.

    What happens next

    The calendar now runs through three dates. Index funds will trade the November changes around 30 November. MSCI's next quarterly review results are due on 9 February 2027, RRI reported. And the big one, the decision on whether Indonesia becomes a standalone market, is due by 30 June 2027.

    For investors, the reforms create a strange situation. In the short term, removing 300 stocks from the benchmark may force more selling. In the long term, a smaller but cleaner index with genuinely tradable shares is exactly what MSCI says it wants. Whether that is enough depends on whether controlling families actually sell down, which is the step the market has resisted for years.

    What to watch over the next seven months:

    • trading in Barito Pacific and Bumi Resources Minerals into 30 November
    • the exchange's final list of the 300 stocks and the date it takes effect
    • whether controlling shareholders sell stock to get off the list
    • foreign flows into and out of Indonesian equities
    • MSCI's February review and its June 2027 reclassification decision

    Did MSCI remove Barito Pacific?

    Yes. In its November 2026 review, MSCI removed Barito Pacific from its Global Standard Indexes, effective after the close on 30 November.

    What happened to Bumi Resources Minerals?

    It was moved from MSCI's Global Standard Indexes to its Global Small Cap Indexes.

    Did MSCI add any Indonesian stocks?

    No. The November review made no Indonesian additions to the Global Standard Indexes.

    How many stocks are in the MSCI Indonesia Index?

    It had shrunk to nine companies after six removals in May and two in August, before the November review removed Barito Pacific and moved Bumi Resources Minerals to small cap, The Business Times reported.

    When do the MSCI changes take effect?

    After the market close on 30 November 2026, with the new composition applying from 1 December.

    What is the IDX high shareholder concentration list?

    A list of stocks with highly concentrated ownership. Companies on it are excluded from the Jakarta Composite Index and MSCI indexes.

    How many stocks will be added to the list?

    About 300, joining 83 already on it, which leaves roughly a third of index members ineligible for the benchmark.

    What are the new criteria?

    They include stocks where 10 or fewer holders own at least 92.5 percent of shares. The 5 trillion rupiah market value threshold is removed.

    How can a company get off the list?

    Its shareholders must sell stock to the public through regular market transactions.

    Will MSCI downgrade Indonesia to a standalone market?

    MSCI has proposed it, is taking feedback until 30 April 2027 and will decide by 30 June 2027.

    How much money could leave Indonesia?

    Goldman Sachs estimated about 5.6 billion dollars of passive outflows if Indonesian stocks were excluded from MSCI indexes.

    How much has the Jakarta Composite Index fallen in 2026?

    More than 41 percent, the worst performance of any major stock market.

    Which Philippine stocks did MSCI remove?

    Manila Electric and PLDT were removed from the Global Standard Indexes in the same review.

    When is MSCI's next review?

    Results of the next quarterly review are due on 9 February 2027.

    Why did MSCI remove Barito Pacific?

    The reports on the review did not give a company specific reason. MSCI's quarterly reviews test size, liquidity and free float, and MSCI has raised concerns about the reliability of free float data in Indonesia.

    Who controls Barito Pacific?

    Billionaire Prajogo Pangestu, one of Indonesia's richest people.

    MSCI and the Indonesia Stock Exchange are now pulling in the same direction, which is unusual and costly. MSCI keeps cutting Indonesian names until it trusts the market's ownership data; the exchange is cutting hundreds more itself to prove it can be trusted. Barito Pacific's removal is the latest price of a market built on thin free floats, and the decision that matters most, standalone status, is still seven months away.

    Talk to the SpinDepth desk

    You've finished this story

    Read on, send it to someone, or ask about it.

    Up next · RegulationIndonesia hits Sinar Mas and Prajogo-linked stocks with record 117 million dollar fines, as Prabowo tells MSCI "we fear no one"

    Send this story