Is a company that mostly holds bitcoin still a company? MSCI has decided that, for its indexes, it is not. In its November review, the index provider listed Strategy, the largest corporate bitcoin holder in the world, for deletion after the close on 30 November, along with Japan's Metaplanet and crypto treasury firm Upexi, Cointelegraph reported. Ether treasury company Sharplink was put on a watchlist.
The timing is brutal. Bitcoin is trading around 69,000 dollars, well below the prices at which many of these companies bought, and the market already values several of them at less than the bitcoin they own. Here is how the biggest bitcoin treasury companies compare on holdings, valuation and debt as the index money prepares to leave.
Why MSCI is removing Strategy
MSCI adopted new rules in October for what it calls non operating companies, to keep businesses that mainly hold financial assets out of indexes meant to track operating companies, Decrypt reported. The deletion removes Strategy's shares from the MSCI USA Index and, through it, from the widely tracked MSCI World and All Country World indexes.
Strategy's own numbers show why the question arose. It reported net income of 19.53 billion dollars for the latest quarter, but nearly all of it came from the rise in the accounting value of its bitcoin, while its software business earned 125.4 million dollars of revenue, down 3 percent from a year earlier. Strategy called the proposal "discriminatory, arbitrary, and misguided" in an August letter to MSCI.
The selling may be smaller than the headline. Strategy estimated that MSCI linked funds hold about 13 million of its shares, 3.1 percent of the total and less than a day's trading, while JPMorgan had estimated earlier that exclusion could trigger about 2.8 billion dollars of selling. The bigger risk, Decrypt noted, is to Strategy's funding model: it raises money by selling shares to buy bitcoin, and a lower share price means fewer bitcoin per share issued.
The discount problem: mNAV below 1
The single most important number for these companies is mNAV, the market value of the company divided by the value of its bitcoin. Above 1, investors pay a premium for the company's ability to raise money and buy more bitcoin. Below 1, the company is worth less than its coins. On BitcoinTreasuries.net data at a bitcoin price of about 69,050 dollars, Strategy traded at 1.06, Strive at 1.00, Nakamoto at 0.88, Metaplanet at 0.74 and Twenty One Capital at 0.68.
A discount turns the strategy upside down. A company trading below its bitcoin value cannot issue shares to buy more bitcoin without destroying value for existing holders, so the flywheel that drove these stocks stops. That is why Strategy's shares, at 114.41 dollars on 12 November, were down about 51 percent over 52 weeks, according to Stock Analysis, even though it still holds more than 850,000 bitcoin.
A bitcoin treasury company trading below its bitcoin is a fund that cannot raise money. MSCI has now decided to treat the whole group like one.

Metaplanet: Asia's biggest bitcoin company, buying back its own shares
Metaplanet, the Tokyo listed company that has become Asia's largest corporate bitcoin holder, is responding to its discount by buying its own stock rather than more bitcoin. Its shares fell 4.37 percent to 219 yen on 13 November, about 66 percent below their 52 week high of 639 yen, crypto.news reported, even though cumulative buybacks had reached 108.7 million shares for 28.27 billion yen.
The average price paid across the programme was about 260 yen, roughly 16 percent above the latest close, so the buybacks have so far cost more than the shares are now worth. Metaplanet is authorised to buy up to 200 million shares for up to 60 billion yen through October 2027. With an mNAV of 0.74, each share is, in theory, a claim on more bitcoin than its price reflects, which is the logic behind the buyback.
Nakamoto: when the debt is bigger than the company
Nakamoto, the company run by David Bailey, shows the downside of borrowing to hold bitcoin. It owes Kraken 165 million USDT, while its shares closed at 5.79 dollars on 12 November for a market value of about 104 million dollars, crypto.news reported. It held 4,283 bitcoin at the end of September, bought at an average of about 118,200 dollars each, well above today's price.
On 12 November Nakamoto pushed its repayments into 2027: 105 million USDT is now due on 30 June 2027 and 60 million on 4 December 2027. About 71 percent of its bitcoin was pledged to Kraken at the end of September, and the company warned that further price falls could force it to repay debt or post more collateral, and that a fall below the liquidation threshold could allow Kraken to sell the pledged coins.
How the treasury companies rank:
- biggest holder: Strategy, 850,364 bitcoin
- biggest in Asia: Metaplanet, 44,000 bitcoin
- deepest discount: Twenty One Capital, mNAV 0.68
- only large holder above 1: Strategy, mNAV 1.06
- most leveraged relative to its size: Nakamoto, with debt above its market value
- biggest buyer of its own shares: Metaplanet, 108.7 million shares bought back

What it means for bitcoin and for Asian investors
The removals do not force anyone to sell bitcoin. They force index funds to sell shares. But corporate treasuries have been one of bitcoin's most reliable buyers, and companies that cannot raise money cheaply will buy less, and in some cases, like Nakamoto earlier this year, sell. Public companies together hold about 1.239 million bitcoin, so their behaviour now moves the market.
For investors in Asia, Metaplanet is the stock most directly affected. The comparison also explains why bitcoin's slide has been so painful for these shares: a 50 percent fall in a company that owns bitcoin at a premium can become a much larger fall when the premium turns into a discount. The Binance hack on 29 October added to the pressure, pushing bitcoin to a six week low at the time, as we set out in our comparison of the biggest crypto heists.
Why is MSCI removing Strategy?
Under new rules adopted in October for non operating companies, MSCI decided Strategy mainly holds financial assets rather than running an operating business. The deletion takes effect after 30 November.
Which companies is MSCI removing?
Strategy, Metaplanet and Upexi, with Sharplink placed on a watchlist, according to Cointelegraph.
How much bitcoin does Strategy own?
850,364 bitcoin, according to BitcoinTreasuries.net, about 69 percent of all bitcoin held by public companies.
What is mNAV?
A company's market value divided by the value of its bitcoin. Below 1 means the company is worth less than its coins.
Which bitcoin treasury company has the biggest discount?
Twenty One Capital, at an mNAV of 0.68, followed by Metaplanet at 0.74.
How much bitcoin does Metaplanet hold?
44,000 bitcoin, making it the largest corporate holder in Asia.
How far has Metaplanet's stock fallen?
To 219 yen on 13 November, about 66 percent below its 52 week high of 639 yen.
Is Metaplanet buying back shares?
Yes. It has bought back 108.7 million shares for 28.27 billion yen and can buy up to 200 million for up to 60 billion yen through October 2027.
How much does Nakamoto owe Kraken?
165 million USDT, more than its market value of about 104 million dollars.
When does Nakamoto have to repay Kraken?
105 million USDT on 30 June 2027 and 60 million USDT on 4 December 2027, after an extension agreed on 12 November.
Will MSCI's decision force a bitcoin sale?
No. It forces index funds to sell the companies' shares, not the companies to sell bitcoin, but it can make it harder for them to raise money to buy more.
How much selling could Strategy's removal cause?
Strategy estimated that MSCI linked funds hold about 13 million shares, 3.1 percent of the total. JPMorgan had estimated about 2.8 billion dollars of selling.
How much bitcoin do public companies hold?
About 1.239 million bitcoin, worth about 85.5 billion dollars at a price of about 69,050 dollars.
Did Trump Media buy bitcoin?
Yes. It bought 4,359 bitcoin in the third quarter and holds 15,649, according to BitcoinTreasuries.net.
The bitcoin treasury trade was built on a premium: investors paid more than a dollar for every dollar of bitcoin these companies held, and the companies used that premium to buy more. With bitcoin near 69,000 dollars, most of the premium is gone, MSCI is removing the two largest names from its indexes, and the weakest players are renegotiating debts. Strategy's 850,364 bitcoin keep it in a class of its own, but the rest of the field now trades like what MSCI says they are: funds.
Talk to the SpinDepth deskYou've finished this story
Read on, send it to someone, or ask about it.
Media & Reputation
Football
Culture
Experiences
Advertising



